Sunday, 11 May 2014

TOK blog 4

Last week we did a online test in TOK to do with ethics. Some questions asked about percentages or how much money you would get now and later and others asked about situations where peoples lives where in your hands. Now we had done a number of these types of questions in class before. All of them where about " Is it alright to kill one person to save many". Now in my eyes all these questions are silly. In theory, killing the one is the logical thing to do if it means saving many but I think if and when it ever comes to actualy doing that you will be unsure. Can you actualy kill someone? The reward is massive but do you have what it takes? The only way I see me being able to do it is if this person  im killing has done something bad in the past such as kill people or worse. Then I could justify killing someone. This brings me back to the questions on the quiz. Usualy I would answer questions like those with kill one and save the many but for once i decided against it. I dont know what spured that rebellion in me but deep down I knew it was a more realistic answer. In the end we didnt get the test results back anyway so it was a rather short lived rebellion.

1 comment:

  1. Yes, it was a shame we didn't get the results from that, you are supposed to or it's not much help. I can see in your commentary that emotion kicks into play when you hesitate to kill another person, even though your reasoning has led you to the point where you think it might be justified. And of course that is always the issue, it's often easier to do nothing, rather than act.

    So doing nothing becomes a possible way out. The question then is are you as morally responsible for an outcome if you let it happen, as you would be if you caused it to happen? This is a question worth exploring.

    ReplyDelete