Monday, 10 March 2014

TOK blog 3


How do we know what side is right? and what is "right"?

In light of the events happening in Europe it brings up the question of “How do we know which sides view is right?” and “What is right?”.  Lots of countries around the world tend to take sides with Ukraine and see Russia as a threat.  But just before all this was happening I saw this video from a reporter in Ukraine talking about all the violence that went on. To me this didn’t seem like it was “right” either. There has to be some reasons why Crimea want to join Russia. Are their views wrong because they are opposing what the US and other parts of the world believe? I am not educated enough on the situation to give my opinion on what is right or wrong, but then again I don’t think anyone knows the full reasons why and the reasons people feel the way they do. No one is right but no one is wrong. It’s like English class. You may thing its right and the best essay you have ever conjured up but the teacher may have the completely opposite view. In the end it’s the side with more power that ends up dictating what most people end up calling “right”. It is the overwhelming majority of people that believe it should be “that way” and this is what we call “good” that we tend to associate with “right”. Wrong is just everything left over.   In Canada the First Nations where “wrong” because they were there first, and did things the traditional way. The French are “wrong” because they speak French. In USA the African Americans where “wrong” because they were black. The list could go on and on about every country. Russia think Ukraine is “wrong” and US think Russia is “wrong”.

1 comment:

  1. Thanks, Dylan. I would have liked to read more of your thoughts here. You raise an interesting point about how we decide what is 'right'. Sometimes the majority don't actually know collectively what is right - think of the slavery issue in Great Britain. The vast majority of people thought slavery was 'right' and initially it was only a very small minority who were opposed.

    An interesting discussion.

    ReplyDelete